Indian historian Vikram Sampath embroiled in plagiarism row

Indian historian Vikram Sampath has been accused of plagiarism in an article written by him in 2017 as well as copying a passage in his two-volume biography on the Indian political leader Vinayak Damodar Savarkar.

In the first instance, a trio of USA-based historians and academics Rohit Chopra, Ananya Chakravarti and Audrey Truschke, highlighted multiple sentences from Sampath’s 2017 article which appear to have been lifted from articles written by the professor Janaki Bakhle in 2010 and by historian Vinayak Chaturvedi in 2013.

Secondly, they pointed to similarities between a paragraph in Sampath’s two-volume book and a thesis written by a deceased student, Paul Schaffel, an award-winning undergraduate at Wesleyan University.

In fact, Bakhle was also stunned to read her portion of the article in Vikram’s book. She said that the “essay gives the impression that Sampath is claiming my ideas and words as his own,” and “would be understood as such by readers.”

The three professors notified the concerned people about the matter by writing two letters to the Royal Historical Society (RHS) in the month of February indicating that Sampath had copied several sentences or paraphrased from other sources without attributing them to original source.

To back up their claims, they submitted evidence of original essays, and claimed to have used Turnitin software, which revealed that 52% of the content was plagiarized. Lastly, they requested the society to re-evaluate Sampath’s recent admittance as member to the society.

The RHS responded by issuing a letter which stated that popular historians play an important role in the community but “plagiarists cannot” and “Dr. Sampath’s predations against other academics, including members of the Society and against vulnerable unpublished student scholars, is in breach of both the letter and spirit of the Society’s stated ethics.”

The three professors even issued an open letter about the allegation on Twitter. Sampath, for his part, has refuted all the allegations as baseless and claimed that he has provided proper citations in his work. He even moved the court seeking a permanent ban on the letter on social media and demanded INR20 million in damages.

While the lawsuit is ongoing, the High Court has passed an interim order prohibiting the three authors from posting the letter or any other defamatory material related to Sampath on Twitter or any other online or offline platforms till the next hearing.

PitchMark helps innovators deter idea theft, so that clients get the idea but don’t take it. Visit PitchMark.net and register for free as a PitchMark member today.

Topics

Legal affairs

Categories

Rip-off or not: Bored Ape Yacht Club vs Bored Wukong

Another day, another kerfuffle in the world of non-fungible tokens (NFTs) — and this time, the fuss is all about cartoon monkeys.
The Bored Ape Yacht Club is an NFT project that has attracted a lot of interest from celebrities. It comprises a collection of 10,000 illustrations of apes, and digital ownership of these gives buyers bragging rights, the ability to monetise their ape avatars v

Who owns the IP rights to HK icon Anita Mui’s life and legacy?

Anita, a biopic about Hong Kong pop icon Anita Mui, drew critical praise and achieved commercial success when it was released last year. However, the movie has also sparked litigation from the late entertainer’s brother, who claims that the film’s production company has infringed on his rights over two registered trademarks.
According to the South China Morning Post, Peter Mui, Anita’s elder b

Novelist John Hughes in hot water over plagiarism accusations

Sydney-based Australian writer-novelist John Hughes and his work "The Dogs" is under intense scrutiny these past few weeks due to allegations of plagiarism. The Guardian Australia investigated and found multiple similarities and identical instances from another literary work, Svetlana Alexievich’s The Unwomanly Face of War. The issue has caused Hughes' work to be removed from the longlist for the

Did Asghar Farhadi plagiarise the idea for “A Hero” movie from his student?

Oscar-winning Iranian director Asghar Farhadi has been accused of stealing the concept of his successful movie A Hero from his former student Azadeh Masihzadeh.
Masihzadeh had filed a case against Farhadi in a Tehran court for plagiarising the concept from her documentary All Winners All Losers, which was made for a workshop led by Farhadi in 2014. The movie was also shown at a film festival i

Let your clients get the idea, without taking it.

PitchMark deters idea theft and provides you with options if it happens.

PitchMark protects the expression of your original concepts, designs, proposals, business plans, creative pitches, music - in short, any idea that you conceived and published, and claim as your own. It gives you peace-of-mind by signalling to whoever you share it with that you are its creator, and that you wish to be respected as such.

If you receive or evaluate ideas or pitches, join PitchMark as a sign of your commitment to respect the Intellectual Property rights of their creators. Attract more in-depth pitches from a wider range of sources. Highlight your PitchMark membership in your Sustainability or CSR Report.