Photo from StockX website

News - 11 February 2022 13:30

Nike sues StockX for violating trademarks over NFTs

Non-fungible tokens or NFTs continue to be in vogue in 2022, but so have the confusions and legal issues arising from them. In the latest round of actions, Nike has sued StockX for violating trademarks by selling its digital tokens without permission.

StockX is a US-based online resale marketplace that sells streetwear, handbags, and other goods, valued at about US$3.8 billion. In January, it launched Vault as its first NFT project that allows customers to buy or sell digital sneakers without possessing them.

An NFT is a digital file on a blockchain that shows who owns a unique piece of digital content. Currently, StockX has about 27,065 sneakers and 1,377 streetwear listed under ‘Nike’, and five under the 'Nike NFT' search words.

Nike claims it has already sold over 500 NFTs associated with the brand. In the 50-page suit, it alleges that StockX is competing in the NFT market “not by taking the time to develop its own intellectual property rights, but rather by blatantly freeriding, almost exclusively” on Nike’s trademarks and “associated goodwill”.

The sportwear giant says that StockX is minting NFTs using Nike’s trademarks, and selling those NFTs at “heavily inflated prices to unsuspecting consumers” without Nike’s approval or authorization

Nike believes those unsanctioned products are likely to confuse consumers and create a false association between those products and the brand.

These allegations are not surprising as Nike also entered the Metaverse last month by acquiring RTFKT Studios (pronounced “artifact”) which sells digital items in the form of NFTs. So, it would not want anybody else to trade its digital assets.

StockX rejected the claims by stating that the lawsuit lacks merit and is based on a mischaracterization of the service offered by StockX through NFT.

Fights between established brands and unauthorized NFTS have increased in recent times. Hermes, a luxury goods company, sent a notice to MetaBirkins to remove NFTS from OpenSea platform while Darden Restaurants, owner of Olive Garden, requested the marketplace to remove all images related to the restaurant to avoid confusing consumers. HitPiece, a music NFT marketplace, was also asked to remove digital assets of music that were sold without the original creators’ consent.

Nike may not be able settle the dispute quickly as StockX is also a company rather than an ordinary collectibles creator like other NFT designers. However, the case is poised to create a benchmark for future NFT copyright issues.

PitchMark helps innovators deter idea theft, so that clients get the idea but don’t take it. Visit PitchMark.net and register for free as a PitchMark member today.

Topics

Legal affairs

Contacts

Mark Laudi

Press contact Managing Partner service@pitchmark.net (+65) 6223 2249

Digital ownership, the birth of a new concept

The following article by Sophie Goossens was first published here by global law firm Reed Smith. It is re-published here with Reed Smith's permission.

Ownership, a legal concept almost as old as humanity, is being tested by the advent of the metaverse - an always-online, persistent, spatial 'second' world. The staggering rise in popularity of non-fungible tokens (NFTs) demonstrates ho

2 December 2021 18:29

5 reasons innovators should use PitchMark

Prevention is better than cure. That’s why when we buy a vehicle, we buy an insurance plan for it too. But what safeguards do innovators have when it comes to their ideas?
That’s where PitchMark comes in. Idea theft is a problem that many innovators face, and the financial loss and hurt feelings that arise from seeing your ideas copied by others without consent, credit and compensation can be

8 November 2022 10:26

Coachella accuses ‘Coachillin’ Business Park of trademark infringement

The Coachella Valley Music and Arts Festival's organizers have accused a cannabis business park in California of trademark infringement for adopting and using the term "Coachillin".
Coachillin Holdings and several associated entities have been accused of taking advantage of a common hashtag and expression associated with the music festival.
In the lawsuit, AEG’s Goldenvoice, the owner of the

7 June 2022 14:27

Did Nike really come up with the 'Ballin' concept, or was it Adobe Bryant who pitched it to them?

Graphic designer Landon T. Jones has filed an idea theft suit against Nike for stealing his design for the NCAA’s “March Madness” promotional campaign.
Jones, aka Adobe Bryant, claims to have pitched his idea to Nike’s marketing executive in April 2020 by providing a Dropbox link.
He further claims that the executive looked at the deck multiple times, but never contacted him to approve or re

Imaara Mall (Left) & image design from Temi Coker's Behance account (Right)

11 April 2022 09:25

Rip-off or not: Nairobi’s Imaara Mall accused of stealing the work of a creative designer

The Imaara retail mall in Nairobi has been accused of copying the work of a Nigerian graphic designer-cum-photographer based in the United States.
The newly opened mall's external walls were painted with a style of art that closely resembles Temi Coker's designs on his Behance account.
Temi began creating his own unique design styles shortly after leaving Adobe in 2019. Since then, his desig

30 March 2022 10:25

PitchMark is now on Medium.com too

PitchMark is pleased to announce that our content is now available on the Medium platform as well.
We are excited about engaging Medium’s community of creators and innovators, and will continue raising awareness of the importance of registering their valuable intellectual property before sharing it with the world.
If you’re on Medium and want to help us get to know this new universe better,

4 April 2022 12:45

Rip-off or not: Croatia coin design winner blamed for plagiarism

The winner of Croatia’s coin logo competition is accused of copying the design from a 17-year-old photo taken by a Scottish photographer and has since withdrawn from the competition and returned the prize money.
Croatia needs a new coin design for circulation as it is adopting the Euro currency in 2023. To achieve this goal, the country’s central bank had organized a competition for the best de

4 November 2022 14:08

NFTs are distinguishable, hence can be deemed property - Singapore High Court rules

A new decision from the Singapore court highlights the nature of non-fungible tokens (NFTs) and the applicability of existing laws to such relatively novel technologies.

The High Court of the Republic of Singapore has ultimately determined that NFTs may be considered property and thus "be the subject of a proprietary injunction”.
The order is in reference to an injunction from May

9 January 2023 12:36

Manchester United accused of copying NFT from artist

The NFT collection that Manchester United introduced on Tezos sold out far more quickly than anticipated, but it is accused of copying from another well-known Tezos NFT artist.
On December 28, NFT artist Lucréce tweeted that he was in discussions with Arthur Breitman, co-founder of Tezos, to ask Manchester United why its new NFT line incorporates his designs and aesthetics.
Lucréce’s collect

5 October 2022 10:30

China steps up its commitment to protect creators’ works from being infringed in the NFT space

In a bid to protect copyright and stimulate creativity, the Chinese Government has intensified its efforts to monitor people who copy other creative works without their consent to create non-fungible tokens (NFTs).
The National Copyright Administration (NCA) will clamp down on offences such as the minting of NFTs based on other people’s works like art, cartoons, music, video games, etc without

17 January 2023 10:00

Donald Trump accused of using copyright-protected images in his NFT collection

Former US president Donald Trump has been accused of using copyright-protected photos in his NFT collection, with social media users calling his money-making endeavor a "scam".
Last month, Trump launched 45,000 photos as an NFT collection called ‘Collect Trump Cards’, or ‘Trump Digital Trading Cards’ as it’s officially known on OpenSea.
The collection, which depicts him as various characters

31 May 2022 09:43

Can IP laws protect your work from being ripped off when evolving technologies are constantly changing the rules of the game?

Content creation is at an all-time high due to platforms such as Meta, TikTok, Instagram, and YouTube, and the advent of new technologies such as NFTs has brought all kinds of challenges for IP lawyers when it comes to protecting your innovations or creations.
World Intellectual Property Day is an annual event that is celebrated on April 26. The theme of this year’s event was “IP and Youth: